I think part of the magic is the stakes, and spending the whole show trying to figure out whether the guy *truly* isn't in on it; what the bounds of the canon are and how honest the creators are being with you.
And in that sense, the second season has some of that same magic, because it really just strains the hell out of my credulity.
They're making another season of Jury Duty? No way they capture that magic again
I think part of the magic is the stakes, and spending the whole show trying to figure out whether the guy *truly* isn't in on it; what the bounds of the canon are and how honest the creators are being with you.
And in that sense, the second season has some of that same magic, because it really just strains the hell out of my credulity.